|
Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The Metrics Trap: Are You Measuring the Right Things?
I can’t tell you how many times I’ve heard marketers and executives say, “Our organic content doesn’t do much of anything, which is why we don’t do much.”
Then I look at their content. And guess what? It’s all holiday promotions, generic company updates, or what looks like an ad but posted organically. Of course, it’s not doing anything. It wasn’t built to. Marketing isn’t just about throwing things out into the world and hoping the numbers look good. It’s about figuring out what those numbers actually mean and using them to make smarter, more profitable decisions.
Yet, most companies get distracted by vanity metrics—clicks, likes, impressions—without questioning if those numbers mean anything beyond looking good on a report.
Yes, engagement has value. The algorithms reward it. But the real question isn’t how many people saw your post—it’s what happened next?
If you’re not tracking where people paused, what content they skipped, how far they scrolled, and what actions they took afterward, you’re flying blind. And that’s how marketing budgets get wasted.
Vanity Metrics vs. The Metrics That Actually Matter
Not all metrics are created equal. Some tell you what you need to know. Others just make you feel like you’re making progress.
- Impressions – Someone saw your content? Cool. But did they care?
- Click-through rate (CTR) – They clicked, but did they take meaningful action?
- Likes and shares – Feels nice, but did it lead to conversions?
Now compare that to metrics that actually impact revenue:
- Time on page & scroll depth – Did people actually consume your content?
- Retention & repeat visits – Are they coming back for more?
- Conversion path analysis – What steps did they take before becoming a customer?
- Multi-touch attribution – How many interactions did it take to convert?
Here’s the kicker: It often takes seven or more brand impressions before a decision-maker feels comfortable buying from a new brand.
If you’re only tracking first-click or last-click attribution, you’re missing the full customer journey—the part where trust and interest are built.
Not All Engagement is Created Equal
A lot of businesses celebrate engagement—likes, shares, comments—without asking the one question that actually matters:
“Is this leading anywhere?”
Because here’s the truth: Some engagement is just noise.
- A post might rack up hundreds of likes… from people who will never buy.
- A viral moment feels great… until you realize it didn’t translate into leads or sales.
- An ad gets tons of clicks… but people immediately bounce because the landing page doesn’t match their expectations, loads too slowly, or confuses them.
A high click-through rate without conversions isn’t a win—it’s wasted budget.
The brands that scale don’t just chase attention—they track what happens after it.
Why “Just Running Ads” Won’t Save You
A lot of businesses fall into the panic mindset:
“Organic isn’t working, so let’s just run ads.”
Alright, but if your organic content wasn’t resonating, why would it suddenly perform better just because you’re paying for distribution?
Ads don’t fix a broken message. They just amplify it.
This is why organic and paid need to work together:
- Organic helps test content, messaging, and audience engagement at low risk.
- Paid accelerates what’s already working and finds new audiences fast.
- If organic isn’t driving engagement, paid won’t magically turn it into conversions.
If your content doesn’t work organically, it’s probably not going to work in paid either.
Marketing is a Long Game—Most Businesses Quit Too Soon
You wouldn’t go to the gym for three weeks, step on the scale, and quit because you didn’t see a transformation.
Yet, that’s exactly how many businesses treat marketing.
- They post content for a few months, then stop when it doesn’t “go viral.”
- They try running ads, then pull back when they don’t see instant ROI.
- They expect one campaign to make all the difference instead of building consistency.
Marketing is cumulative—it builds over time.
Pulling back on marketing is like slamming the brakes on a moving car—getting back up to speed later is way harder (and more expensive).
Companies that invest in marketing for a year or more don’t just see better numbers—they see a completely different trajectory.
Companies that treat marketing like a fad diet (stop-start, short-term thinking) stay stuck in the same place.
If you want long-term results, you need long-term strategy.
What to Do Now: Start Measuring What Actually Matters
If you want to get real business value from marketing, shift your focus to metrics that drive movement.
Instead of focusing on vanity metrics, track:
- How many repeat visits your content generates
- How long people engage with your content
- How different touchpoints contribute to a sale
- What actually drives revenue—not just attention
Instead of just running ads, ask:
- Does this message already perform well organically?
- Are we targeting high-intent audiences?
- Do we have a strategy for what happens after the ad click?
Instead of quitting too soon, remember:
- Marketing takes time—but the compounding effect is worth it.
- The companies you admire didn’t build overnight.
- If you stop, you don’t just lose growth—you lose momentum.
Final Takeaway: Marketing Success is Built, Not Bought
If you’re treating marketing like a cost center, you’re thinking about it wrong.
Marketing isn’t an expense—it’s the engine that drives visibility, engagement, and revenue.
The best companies:
- Invest early, so they’re not playing catch-up.
- Measure what actually matters, not just what looks good on a report.
- Optimize for long-term revenue impact, not just quick wins.
The question isn’t whether you should invest in marketing.
It’s how much faster you want to grow.If you’re looking for an agency that just “runs ads” or “posts content,” we’re not it. If you want real strategy, execution, and measurable growth—let’s talk.
